Collector Car Insurance Reviews - All

Our Guaranteed Value policies, unparalleled service, and dedication to the hobby sets Hagerty apart from other classic car insurance companies. We work hard to keep our clients happy, and their reviews speak volumes.

Submit a review

Please note that reviews are sorted with the most recent at the top. More robust search options are coming in the next few months.

Select a Category

showing 1-10 of 406 | 1 2 3 41 Next
  • 5

    More Than Satisfied

    I was a new policy holder for only 1 week in Nov. 2013 when I had a fender bender with my classic. I called it in, being very embarrassed, and the Hagerty Staff treated me like old family and handled the damages quickly. You could not ask for more effective and friendly service.
  • 5

    hagerty rapid response

    I just want to relate my story of the time that my coil failed in my 69 stingray on the interstate. Being in my 50s and having had prior heart problems didn't stop me from climbing up the embankment and over a fence before calling hagerty for help! Immediately the representative new I was in distress and offered all the assistance that I could ask for.Excellent company !!!!!
  • 5

    Great coverage

    The amount of insurance I have for all my vehicles is extremely reasonable.
  • 5

    Love This Company

    Not only WOULD I recommend to my friends, I often do. There are those rare companies that are so immediately helpful, so customer-focused, so friendly, that it's a pleasure giving them my money. Hagerty is such a company. Simply the best. (And, even their customer magazine is excellent, and readable...)
  • 5


    Got stuck one night when the harmonic dampener on my C5 Corvette decided to seperate. Call to Hagerty said help would be there within 90 minutes, truck showed up in 30 minutes! I spent more time in the parking lot messing with the belt before calling than I did waiting for the hook. Should have called Hagerty first!
  • 5

    payment system

    It would be great if one could pay with a CC that has an address outside the US ! i live in London and have USD CC's from US banks but I don't have a US address.
    Breanne Says:

    Payment System

    Dear Christopher: Thank you for your valid suggestion regarding our online payment system. I will reach out to our accounting department to ask about enhancing our credit card payment screen to recognize international billing addresses. Once I find out an answer to your inquiry, I will be sure to reach out to you to discuss it in detail. We appreciate your loyal business.
  • 5

    Great Company

    I have been a customer of hagerty insurance for about nine years now and could not be happier with there Customer service and knowledge of Classic Cars,
  • 5

    Right Price and Coverage

    My 86 944 still does not have 30,000 miles on it (purchased new). Insurance cost with Allstate (my Allstate agent recommended Hagerty) was more than twice the yearly coverage of my Hagerty policy. Plus my Hagerty policy is based on my valuation of my Porsche not what Allstate was give me if it was totalled. I have never been in an accident since I started driving in 1967.
  • 5

    excellent service

    I ALWAYS receive excellent service from my Hagerty agent Steve Wingenfelt. I know he will be there when I need him. Thanks
  • 5


    very good service.
showing 1-10 of 406 | 1 2 3 41 Next