Collector Car Insurance Reviews - All

Our Guaranteed Value policies, unparalleled service, and dedication to the hobby sets Hagerty apart from other classic car insurance companies. We work hard to keep our clients happy, and their reviews speak volumes.

Submit a review

Please note that reviews are sorted with the most recent at the top. More robust search options are coming in the next few months.

Select a Category

showing 1-10 of 438 | 1 2 3 44 Next
  • 5

    First timer

    I'm Jerry, and this is my first experience with Hagerty. So far my experience has been nothing but excellent. Not sure who my agent is at the moment, but i can say that they are fast and effiecient. as soon as they receive a fax or response from me, they immediately call to let me know they received it. Also they worked on getting me the best possible coverage on my vehicle fast and prompt. So far I'm very happy with Hagerty and their staff. Hope to continue with them for a very long time.
  • 5


    Went to my very first Car Show this year in Petaluma, Ca. On the way there my alternator went out, causing my electric fan to not function. Had to pull out of the staging line because the truck was starting to overheat. Called the hotline, and toe service came right away. Thanks for the prompt service.
  • 3


    Every year my insurance goes up even though I never had a claim. If this continues I will be looking for another company
    Breanne Says:

    Rate concerns

    Dear Paul: I appreciate you voicing your concerns about the rate increase you've experienced. We try our very best to protect our clients' rates while offering the best possible coverage for classics. There are a variety of factors that affect an insurance risk's rate, and in order to provide you with a sound explanation, it's best to have a conversation by phone. I will have a client care specialist reach out to you today. We thank you for your long-time, loyal business and the opportunity to make things right with you.
  • 5

    Easy to add a car

    Picked up another car, and on the way home with it still on the trailer, stopped by the insurance broker's office. She added the new car to my Hagerty policy in minutes, and I was all insured even before the car got home. Simple!
  • 5

    So impressed!

    I have been so impressed with the customer service and efficient response each time I have had to contact Hagerty. Crystal efficiently switched my insurance from one car to another and informed me of other offerings by Hagerty, including tool insurance! What a great company with great people!
    Breanne Says:

    Happy to hear

    Dear John: Thank you for sharing the positive feedback with us. We really appreciate hearing first-hand how our clients feel about us. I'll be sure to let Crystal, and her manager, know that you were impressed with her great service. Happy motoring in 2015!
  • 5

    Policy Renewals

    Love the website that makes the renewal process easy. Last year I waited to long & received a expiring insurance notice from the state. I called & Hagerty got me back on track quickly with the state insurance requirement.
  • 5

    another policy

    Very fast service, great rates when adding another vehicle, Happy to do business with Hagerty.
  • 5


    Have been with Hagerty for three years now. GREAT EXPERIENCE
  • 4

    Online Payment Process

    Online payment by credit card is a wonderful feature, but you should do as other online vendors do and allow your customers to schedule the date on which their payment will be charged. That allows them to schedule the payment as soon as the renewal offer is received for the date on which it is actually due.
    Breanne Says:

    Payment Screen Enhancement

    Dear Everett: Thanks for taking the time to submit your feedback about how we can improve our online payment screen. I agree that this enhancement would greatly improve the ease of business for our clients. I have submitted the request to our IT department, and I'll be sure to follow up with you once I hear of a solution. We appreciate your patience and your loyal business!
  • 5


    I am very pleased with your service. My agent Carrie is excellent.
    Breanne Says:

    Service Shout Out

    Dear Jerry: We really appreciate you taking the time to mention Carrie's great service. I'll be sure to let her and her manager know that she took good care of you. Thank you for your business!
showing 1-10 of 438 | 1 2 3 44 Next