Collector Car Insurance Reviews - All

Our Guaranteed Value policies, unparalleled service, and dedication to the hobby sets Hagerty apart from other classic car insurance companies. We work hard to keep our clients happy, and their reviews speak volumes.

Submit a review

Please note that reviews are sorted with the most recent at the top. More robust search options are coming in the next few months.

Select a Category

showing 1-10 of 391 | 1 2 3 40 Next
  • 5

    Great service

    Hagerty Insurance for my classic car is the best ! Your representatives are very personable and easy to deal with very knowledgeable . I like the idea of insuring my Chevelle for what I think it is worth ! I bought my 1967 Chevelle brand-new December 20, 1966 when I was eight years old and it's a part of my life now and I could never replace it ! Thank you for being a great classic car insurance company and for your fair prices are the best .
  • 5

    Thank you

    My local Ky Farm Bureau agent Beau Scott has done an excellent job as an agent for Hagerty as well! He is thorough, quick to respond and very knowledgeable! I appreciate his professional demeanor, his organization and above all his work ethic and integrity! Sincerely, Jason Paynter - Louisville, KY
  • 5

    Fast and Easy

    Fast and easy aren't adjectives that normally accompany an insurance renewal process, but you guys have done it. Thanks for the articles and the timely communication of information. Sincerely, Jim
  • 5

    El camino

    My el Camino was rear ended and pushed me into another car. this was on a Thursday I notified Haggerty and the person taking the information was very sypathic and said I would hear from an adjuster on Friday. I said to myself "yeah right") Friday came and to my surprise Adam the adjusted called got the information he needed and said a field adjuster would be out at the beginning of the week, again Yeah right well again to my surprise Tuesday the body shop called to say the adjuster had been there and they had agreed on the price to repair my car. Adam called me again to assure me that everything was in the works and not to worry everything would be taken care of.I couldn't believe how fast and smooth this whole process was, No hassles or aggravation for me. I will definitely recommend Haggerty to all of my friends that drive classics. My thanks to Adam and the Haggerty team DJ Rhode Island
    Breanne Says:

    Claims Response

    Dear Dennis: Thank you for the positive feedback regarding your recent claim experience. We are so happy to hear that you received the service you deserve. I'll be sure to let Adam know that you appreciate his great service. We certainly appreciate your business.
  • 5

    As easy as breathing

    Thank the good Lord for people like Hagerty. I finally moved my 46 Willy's CJ2A old flat fender Jeep to Hagerty. All of my children, nieces and nephews learned to drive in old "Nugget". Nugget sit's most of the time now except in summer weather when the wife and I go for a little cruise's usually with grand kids in the back seat. Hagerty has made justifying the annual cost keeping it to pass on to the next generation.
  • 5

    Convenient, No Hassle Binding Vehicles

    BAM! My 5 policies are renewed & I have printed the policy certificates without talking to a single person at almost midnight-I love it! Freddy O'Pry Freddy O'Pry Enterprises Texas
  • 5

    policy change

    The girl on the phone was very pleasant and super helpful! Thank you!
  • 5

    Storage

    I live in Wisconsin and for at least 5+ months my Collector cars sit in storage, with full coverage. Why isn't there a Storage Policy Available instead of holding full coverage. Would probably attract clients and help out the current holders. Just Wondering?
    Breanne Says:

    Winter Storage

    Dear Phillip: Thank you for taking the time to write a review and inquire about seasonal coverage options. Your question is one that is often asked by our clients. As a company based out of Northern Michigan, we can certainly relate to the woes of our long winters and the fact that you're not subjecting your classic to the elements. We do consider the fact that our clients drive their vehicles very little, if at all, due to seasonal conditions when we assess our annual premiums. I will have one of our agents reach out to you today by phone to discuss further. We appreciate your business!
  • 5

    Yinz Rock.

    This is the first renewal I have had with Hagerty. I received my 77' MG Midget from my father a couple years ago and last year we transferred it into my name officially. I love her, she's a little dream. With Hagerty it has made it even more of a pleasure knowing that I have you on my side. Thanks a Million!
  • 1

    Roadside Service is Horrible

    Unfortunately I had the opportunity to avail myself of the Haggerty Roadside Assistance this past weekend. What I should say is that I got to spend a lot of time on the phone with them but ended up getting my classic bike back home when I had the good luck to be passed by a fellow British bike enthusiast who had a truck a ramp and gave me and my wife a ride home. I have a vintage Triumph Bonneville and was out riding with my wife this weekend when I blew a piston. Pulled the bike to the side of the road, watched the smoke dissipate and pulled out my Haggerty card. It took the girl on the phone about 20 minutes with intermittent holds to collect my info and determine that I needed a truck to come get my motorcycle, my wife and me. An hour after I disconnected with her a guy shows with with a wrecker and tells me that no one told him it was a motorcycle or that he needed a flatbed. I call Haggerty back get a new guy who cancels the current service and tells me he'll call me right back with info on the new service that will come out. I call back 20 mins later to get a status only to be told they are looking for a service provider in my area. I give them the name of a couple that are close (Googled them on my phone), they said they would call me back. Get a call back in 15 mins that tells me that someone will be there in about an hour! As I am on the phone with this guy, a guy in a pickup stops, says he has British bikes and of course keeps a ramp in his truck for just such occasions. Since sitting on the side of a country road for three hours in 95 degree weather was not my idea of a perfect Sunday I accepted his offer and told the folks from Haggerty I had handled it myself. If they handle insurance claims like they handle the roadside assistance I hope I am never in a position where I have to make a claim. Upgrading my AAA membership to include my motorcycle as soon as I'm done with this review.
    Breanne Says:

    Roadside Service Breakdown

    Dear Randy: First of all, I am very sorry that your experience with our roadside assistance was so poor. We appreciate you taking the time to write such a detailed review so we can better investigate the breakdown in the service you received. Someone from our roadside assistance team will be calling you today to talk this through. It's really unfortunate that your first experience with us was such a rough one. We take complaints like this very seriously and will do our best to make it right.
showing 1-10 of 391 | 1 2 3 40 Next