Subscribe to Hagerty Plus member newsletter

Hagerty Magazine

Each issue profiles the people, vehicles, issues and events that make ours such a rich and dynamic hobby.

Tim McNairs Detailing Tips and Tricks

Hagerty

February 24, 2010

DETAILING SUPPLIES

Best in Class =

CATEGORY

PRODUCT

RATING

COMMENTS

CLAY BARS

Griot's

****

Very good. Larger quantity, good value. Similar to Gliptone.

Meguiar's (consumer)

***

Easiest and most mild "consumer" clay, safe

Gliptone

****

Very elastic. Closest to the original clay bar.

Meguiar's (pro) Mild

*****

Top quality, long lasting. Different grits for better results, but it's not cheap.

SPRAY DETAILER

Meguiar's Quik Detailer

***

The standard. Easy to use, and you can buy it almost anywhere. Cleans a dirty car pretty well, but it does smear in high humidity

Meg's Ultimate detailer

****

Better than the original, as it works in humidity. It also leaves more gloss

Griot's Speed Shine

*** +

Good quality, works well with clay.

Prima Hydro

**** +

Use wet or dry. It has wax in it . Best in high humidity.

Prima Slick

****

Super smooth finish, and it works OK in humidity. High gloss.

POLISH (machine)

P21S

****

Very easy to use with orbital or by hand. Offers a deep gloss with little effort.

Meguiar's 205 (Pro line)

*****

This is the latest technology. For best results, use an orbital. Works on all paints, provides excellent results.

Meguiar's # 3

***

The original hand polish. Easy to use, but the new tech is better.

Griot's #3 Machine Polish

****

Use it with an orbital. It's easy to remove and has a nice gloss

Duragloss TPP 105

****

Easy to use by hand or machine. It's excellent on newer paint.

Zymol hd cleanse

**

This has a strong resemblence to Meg's #3, but it's hard to use. Produces only an average gloss compared to P21s or 205.

Poorboys Professional

****

Works well with orbital, OK by hand.

polish

WAX (Paste)

P21S

***

Easy to apply, it has a nice smell, but only average-lasting.

Meguiar's 23 paste wax

**

Easy to apply, but it doesn't last too long.

Pinnacle Souveran

*****

The current front runner is longer lasting, has a deep gloss, goes on and comes off easily.

Poorboys Natty's red

****

Very deep gloss; only Pinnacle looks better. Nice strawberry scent. Good value, but hard to find.

Zymol Carbon, etc.

**

Lacks the gloss of newer technology products, and doesn't last.

INTERIOR CLEANER

Griot's

****

Cleans very well, wipes off clean. Generally mild.

Meguiar's

****

This is a great cleaner. Should be mixed with water. Good value.

(Detailer series)

Simple Green

***

This one's cheap and easy. You can buy it anywhere, and it can be used as grease cutter as well.

LEATHER CLEANER

Lexol

****

Very good cleaner. Can be used on almost all leathers, and works well on Connolly and older cars.

Griot's

***

Cleans well, easy to use.

LEATHER

Lexol

****

Easy to use and buy. Use sparingly and wipe off after a little time. Best on older leathers, but be sure to test it first.

PRESERVATIVE

Leatherique

****

This one's most versatile; it's great on all leathers. Easy one step.

Prima Nourish

***

Smells great, and it's better on newer cars. Goes on easily, not greasy.

Griot's

***

Good quality; it compares to Prima and Lexol brown.

VINYL/

Griot's

***

Easy to use, although maybe a little glossy. Good on almost all vinyl and rubber.

RUBBER DRESSING

Prima Nero

****

This one's good on vinyl, and dries to perfect semi-gloss.

Wurth Cockpit Cleaner

***

Satin finish, but it's expensive and hard to find. It's Excellent on hard plastic.

Lexol Vinylex

***

Works well and it lasts. It can be slimy if it's not buffed off.

Meguiar's #40

*** +

Second to Prima. It's a good product with a semi-gloss finish. Great on rubber mats as well.

PLASTIC CLEANER/

Plexus

*****

Easy spray-on, improves gloss and clarity, fills hairline scratches. Excellent.

POLISH

3M

***

Easy liquid polish. Works well. Follow with Plexus for a great shine.

Novus

****

3 steps. Very good. It can restore milky or scratched plastic.

POLISH (HAND)

P21s Paintwork Cleanser

****

See above. Easy to remove by hand.

Griot's Hand Polish

***

Very good, but P21s outperforms.

WAX (liquid)

Prima Epic

*****

Latest technology is a synthetic wax. Offers a wet look, long lasting, very deep gloss.

Griot's Best of Show

****

Easy on, not so easy off. Nice gloss.

Poorboys EX-P

***

Easy to use, paste outshines by far. Doesn't last as long as others. Synthetic.

TIRE CLEANER

Westley's Bleche White

***

The original whitewall cleaner. Great on all rubber, but rinse it off well. Easy to use and find.

Griot's

***

Cleans well, use brush to agitate

Meguiar's APC

***

From their Detailer's series, this is a good value. You can dilute for other uses.

degreaser

Lacquer thinner

****

Great on white walls, but use sparingly and carefully. Not for the faint of heart.

COMPOUND

Meguiars 105

*****

Excellent results with rotary or orbital buffer, and offers an easy clean up. Good by hand. Removes sanding scratches.

3M machine compound

****

Very good. Best for sanding marks. Use with rotary buffer.

3M extra cut

****

Difficult to use, and you can damage paint. For professional use only. Very good to remove sanding marks.

TIRE DRESSING

Prima Nero

*****

Works best on tires, low gloss, lasts a long time.

Meguiar's Endurance

****

Available in low and high gloss, this is an easy-to-use gel formula. Stays on when applied.

Griot's tire dressing

****

A little glossy, but goes on easily and it can be buffed out. Neat applicator.

SWIRL REMOVER

Prima Amigo

****

Super wet look finish when followed by Prima Epic.

Meguiar's #9

***

Good quality, not as responsive as newer tech products.

swirl remover

3M Swirl remover

***

This one can be tricky. It's a true professional product, dependent on pad/buffer combo. Good results.

GLAZES

3M Imperial Hand Glaze

***

This is popular in the Hot Rod world. It's a short-term fix for long-term paint problems.

Meguiar's #7 show car glaze

**

Used to be considered to be THE product to use, but it's average compared to newer tech products.

CLEANER/WAXES

Meguiars Gold Class

***

Better than average carnauba based.

(ONE STEP)

Meguiar's (red bottle)

**

Average gloss and longevity, but it's the highest rated at Consumer's.

Meguiar's #6

**

Just okay; it doesn't last.

Meguiar's NXT

***

Polymer formula provides a big shine for a short time.

Zymol

***

Smells great, works OK.

Prima Banana Gloss

****

Smells weird, excellent shine, apply in layers for more gloss.

Mother's

**

Old tech, similar to Meguiar's.

Mother's

***

More like NXT, provides good gloss.

Reflection series

Duragloss TPP 105

****

One of the best in class. Offers great depth and shine. Can be "topcoated" with wax.

Poorboys polish

***

Good shine lasts as long as the others.

with Carnauba

Poorboys polish

***

Better shine, lasts longer than blue Poorboys.

with sealant

METAL POLISH

P21S

***

Excellent polish is good on chrome. It removes light staining on exhaust tips.

Wenol

***

See above, similar to p21s.

Flitz

***

See above, like wenol and P21S.

Mothers mag and aluminum

**

Old school trick may be a little more abrasive than it needs to be.

Meguiars metal polish

**

Similar to Mother's

Gliptone (Heavy Metal) blue

***

Liquid or cotton based wadding. Works well on most metals. Wadding is very convenient.

Simichrome

***

The original. Comparable to Flitz, etc. A little more aggressive.

Nuvite

*****

The best. Grade S is superb. Use on any metal from titanium to brass. Different grits available.

Rolite

**** +

Similar to Nuvite but not as diverse in product line. Nuvite edges slightly on overall shine.

Bottom of Form

Comments

  1. leather conditioner leather cleaner Gliptone products rated #1 Worldwide survey by Classic & Sports Car Mag. Kerry Haas Gliptone User

  2. Chris E.

    Great info sharing and appreciated! Thanks

  3. Great list but I would like to see the independent ratings on Ibiz products.

  4. Thanks. A no-nonsense, easy to read format. Helpful & inspires me to try products I might not have previously considered.

  5. Gary H. Left Coast

    WHAT A GREAT LIST! This is why I have Hagerty!

  6. Printed out the list and it now sits in the garage for isntant checking of what to buy.

  •  
  •   
  •  
  •